P.J. O'Rourke Gets It

P.J. O'Rourke provides a typically very funny commentary in the Wall Street Journal on the fallacy of President Obama's redistributionist thinking.  O'Rourke points out that this thinking starts from the false premise that there is only so much wealth to go around, so if some have more it is because they have made others have less--the "zero-sum" fallacy.  (O'Rourke and others would help the argument if they pointed out, as I have, that the reason this is a fallacy is because wealth is created with economic activity, not merely transferred, so when some are better off it is almost always because they have made others better off, too.  The economy, free of unnecessary government intervention, is a positive-sum activity.)

As I have observed earlier in this blog, Obama's attack on the "rich" is not really intended to help the "poor," for whom the President rarely expresses any concern.  Rather, he seeks to punish the inventors, innovators, job-creators and wealth-creators (derided as "the rich"), for no apparent reason other than to punish them, and certainly not to help those in poverty.  Thus, Obama doesn't wage a War on Poverty; he wages a War on Prosperity.  O'Rourke completely gets it, and he says it much funnier than I can:

In this zero-sum universe there is only so much happiness. The idea is that if we wipe the smile off the faces of people with prosperous businesses and successful careers, that will make the rest of us grin.

There is only so much money. The people who have money are hogging it. The way for the rest of us to get money is to turn the hogs into bacon.

Mr. President, your entire campaign platform was redistribution. Take from the rich and give to the . . . Well, actually, you didn't mention the poor. What you talked and talked about was the middle class, something most well-off Americans consider themselves to be members of. So your plan is to take from the more rich and the more or less rich and give to the less rich, more or less. It is as if Robin Hood stole treasure from the Sheriff of Nottingham and bestowed it on the Deputy Sheriff.